The Vatican rejected an appeal by a parishioner in the Diocese of Charlotte, North Carolina, and has upheld Bishop Michael Martin's prohibition of the use of altar rails and kneelers in the reception of Communion.
In a letter dated Aug. 3, Archbishop Vittorio Francesco Viola, OFM, then-Secretary of the Dicastery for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, responded to a father who said he and his family had been denied the sacrament when they chose to kneel at the altar rail despite Martin's instructions that the faithful should stand while receiving holy Communion, even in parishes with fixed altar rails.
In the Vatican letter, first reported on by AdVaticanum, Viola wrote that after examining "the applicable universal and particular liturgical norms," the dicastery found "no grounds for granting" the hierarchical recourse requested by the father, upholding Martin's prohibition against kneeling at the altar rail.
Viola said Martin's "provisions neither deny the faithful access to the Sacrament of the Holy Eucharist nor prohibit the reception of Holy Communion while kneeling, which remains permitted according to the universal and particular liturgical discipline currently in force" in the United States.
He said that Martin's norms are concerned with the "external manner" in which Communion is distributed, meaning they govern the use of "altar rails, kneelers and prie-dieus," and defended Martin's authority as bishop to "regulate these matters in accordance" with canon law.
Viola said the faithful do not have the right to "determine individually the place and manner in which they present themselves" to receive Communion. They are still free to kneel "at the moment of reception," he wrote, and cannot be denied Communion at that moment.
Martin acknowledged this in his December 2025 letter, writing that while an "individual member of the faithful" is free to kneel to receive and should not be denied Communion, the "normative posture for all the faithful in the United States is standing," per guidelines from the U.S. bishops.
In May 2025, a leaked draft of a letter detailed Martin's intended reforms of traditional practices in the diocese. In the letter, the bishop said that because "there is no mention in the conciliar documents, the reform of the liturgy, or current liturgical documents concerning the use of altar rails or kneelers for the distribution of holy Communion, they are not to be employed in the Diocese of Charlotte."
Martin also ordered the removal of all "temporary or movable fixtures used for kneeling," including prie-dieux (movable kneelers).
Also in the May letter, Martin said it was "simply absurd" to suggest that "kneeling is more reverent than standing."
Viola encouraged the faithful to "willingly adopt the manner indicated by their pastors" so that the reception of the Eucharist "may truly manifest the unity of those gathered around the one table of the Lord," citing the General Instruction of the Roman Missal's teaching "that a common posture observed by all participants is itself a sign of the unity of the Christian community assembled for the sacred liturgy."
Martin's prohibition has faced a great deal of pushback in the diocese.
In January, more than 30 priests in the Charlotte Diocese signed a letter to the Vatican's Dicastery for Legislative Texts containing a set of questions, or "dubia," related to Martin's prohibition.
The priests directly questioned "whether a diocesan bishop may prohibit the use of kneelers to assist members of the faithful who, of their own accord, wish to receive holy Communion kneeling," reported The Pillar, which obtained a leaked copy of the diocesan priests' letter at the time.
A priest in the diocese who wished to remain anonymous due to an alleged "atmosphere of fear, retaliation, and mistrust" told EWTN News at the time that the actual number of the dubia's supporters was "well north" of the 31, or a quarter of all priests in the diocese, who actually signed it.
A spokesperson for the Diocese of Charlotte told EWTN News in January that the bishop "has not 'restricted kneeling.'"

