Media outlets aligned with the Nicaraguan dictatorship released a video showing Bishop Abelardo Mata, bishop emeritus of Estelí, whose whereabouts have been unknown since late June.
In the video, whose recording date is unknown, the 80-year-old prelate, who celebrates his golden jubilee of priesthood on Aug. 15, is seen conversing with a journalist and pro-government lawmaker Adolfo Pastrán.
Among other things, Pastrán remarks that the bishop looks "full of vitality," to which the bishop briefly replies that "prayer helps a great deal" and that he is doing well.
'I'm in my element here, living a monastic life'
Throughout the nine minutes of footage, the two are seen discussing personal anecdotes, Mata's fondness for tending to his crops and plants, and his reading habits at the estate where he lives in Tisma, Masaya district, the location where the dictatorship says the bishop has been since July 4 following his detention in late June.
Tweet< async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8">
Regarding whether he receives visitors, the bishop mentions that "a brother and a niece" have come to see him and that he enjoys "silence, study, and prayer. I am in my element, leading a monastic life; that is what I am doing — prayer and intellectual work."
'Pro-government propagandist'
Speaking on Aug. 14 to ACI Prensa, the Spanish-language sister service of EWTN News, Father Edwing Román, vicar of St. Agatha Parish in Miami, criticized the release of the video. He described Pastrán as a "pro-government propagandist" who fails to mention "anything about the bishop being intercepted by police as he left a clinic in Estelí."
"They kept him under restrictions and incommunicado for weeks in addition to trying to tarnish his reputation for integrity by questioning him about his property," he added.
When Mata was detained, the dictatorship of President Daniel Ortega and his wife and vice president, Rosario Murillo, issued a statement noting that the prelate had been subjected to a "necessary inquiry regarding the origin of properties and family ties inconsistent with his priestly status" and that, subsequently, "he has returned to his home, where he remains in perfect condition."
Tweet< async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8">
Román also noted that "Bishop Mata has always been a critical voice and deeply attuned to the suffering of the Nicaraguan people. His arbitrary detention — being confined to his own home — is part of the pattern of harassment the Church in Nicaragua is facing."
"This video," the priest emphasized, "appears in response to pressure from Nicaraguans and, above all, the United States; yet it neither shows nor mentions the police patrols stationed at the property, where the bishop is not free to leave."
In mid-July, the U.S. government reiterated its demand for the "immediate and unconditional release of Bishop Abelardo Mata" in a statement by Deputy Assistant Secretary of State Riley Barnes.
'The same script' used with Bishop Rolando Álvarez
Arturo McFields Yescas, Nicaragua's former ambassador to the Organization of American States, told ACI Prensa that "Nicaragua's dictatorship has repeated the same script they used with Bishop Rolando Álvarez. They changed the scenery and the persons being interviewed a bit, but it's the same script."
"The dictatorship presents a bishop who is being held captive, who is a 'disappeared' person deprived of his freedom, yet who appears well, healthy, in excellent physical condition, and well nourished," he noted.
In November 2023, as various institutions were demanding proof of life from the Nicaraguan regime regarding Rolando Álvarez, the bishop of Matagalpa and apostolic administrator of Estelí, the dictatorship released a series of images showing the prelate, who had been unjustly imprisoned since February of that year. In January 2024, he was expelled from the country and now lives in exile in Rome.
In McFields' view, the release of the video featuring Mata demonstrates that "we are living under a regime of terror and lies. Bishop Juan Abelardo Mata remains held against his will, and people want to see him free. They do not want partial or illusory freedom. What we are witnessing is another staged performance."
"No one believes the charade they put on, claiming that Bishop Mata was calm, relaxed, and in robust health. No one believes that lie. The video most likely dates back several weeks or months. It lacks credibility, and so does the interviewer," he added.
"Free the bishop and put an end to religious persecution in Nicaragua," urged the former Nicaraguan ambassador. "The life of Bishop Juan Abelardo Mata is in grave danger as long as he remains held captive by the dictatorship," he declared.
Day of prayer for Mata
Mata led the Diocese of Estelí for more than 30 years, from April 1990 to July 2021.
Mata was ordained a priest on Aug. 15, 1976. To mark this anniversary, a group of Nicaraguans in exile is encouraging a day of prayer for the prelate this Saturday, Aug. 15, "in all parishes and Catholic centers in Nicaragua and around the world."
The exiles are calling for Masses to be celebrated and the rosary to be prayed, as well as for the offering of the traditional "thousand Hail Marys" for Mata "for his life, his well-being, and his freedom," and "for his swift release and protection."
"On this Aug. 15, the Nicaraguan Church gives thanks for his golden jubilee of priesthood and lifts up prayers for the priest, the shepherd, and the brother who today also needs to be accompanied and upheld in prayer," the group stated.
This story was first published by ACI Prensa, the Spanish-language sister service of EWTN News. It has been translated and adapted by EWTN News English.

