http://www.myspiritfm.com/News?blogid=8838&view=post&articleid=303525&link=1&fldKeywords=&fldAuthor=&fldTopic=0
A German auxiliary bishop has said the Catholic Church "could afford" to ordain married men as priests while firmly rejecting demands for the ordination of women to the priesthood ahead of a crucial gathering of German bishops later this month.
Auxiliary Bishop Josef Graf of Regensburg told the Catholic Sunday newspaper of the Diocese of Bolzano-Brixen in an interview published Sept. 15 that he personally believes the Church could open the door to so-called "viri probati" — men of proven faith who are married.
"I personally believe the Church could afford 'viri probati.' It could grant ordination to 'proven men' with a marriage and a family," Graf said.
The German prelate pointed out that the Diocese of Regensburg had several married priests — former Protestant pastors who converted to Catholicism and were ordained with Rome's permission while continuing to live in marriage and family.
"We also recognize the priestly ordination of the Orthodox churches and of the Eastern Catholic churches of the Byzantine rite. These have married priests alongside the monastic state," Graf said. "I could well imagine the Church taking the path of 'viri probati.' But the priest shortage would probably not be eliminated by it."
Celibacy 'not indispensable'
Graf, 69, who served as seminary spiritual director for 26 years before his episcopal appointment in 2015, affirmed the value of priestly celibacy but said it is not a prerequisite for ordination.
"I still believe that the celibacy of the priest has not only a great tradition in the Catholic Church but is also a charism that is helpful in the exercise of priestly ministry," he said.
Celibacy, when lived honestly, Graf added, will always involve renunciation of sexual intimacy, and "the lifelong partnership of marriage, of having one's own children."
"Celibacy, as an expression of following Christ, will always also involve the way of the cross. However, the unmarried state of the priest would not be a 'conditio sine qua non' — an indispensable prerequisite — for receiving priestly ordination," he said.
The celibacy lived by ordained men and women in the Latin Church is rooted in the example of Christ, who lived unmarried. It enables the priest to serve his community with undivided attention and functions as an eschatological sign pointing to the fullness of communion with God, in which "they neither marry nor are given in marriage" (Mt 22:30). Pope Paul VI described celibacy in Sacerdotalis Caelibatus (1967) as the object and outward sign of a complete and generous self-giving to the mystery of Christ.
Women's ordination rejected
Graf firmly rejected calls for the ordination of women, a demand raised by Germany's Synodal Way process.
"I believe that is not possible. Already because we have a different tradition," he said. "If a pope were to break with this tradition, it would at present lead to a split in the Church."
Asked whether tradition was the only argument against it, Graf replied: "Not at all. In my view there are still very weighty theological reasons for the sacrament of ordination being reserved to men. Listing them here would require too much space."
The Catholic Church holds that only men can be validly ordained to the priesthood, a teaching declared as definitive by St. John Paul II in his 1994 apostolic letter Ordinatio Sacerdotalis. The teaching applies analogously to the diaconate and the episcopate.
Ordination numbers and 'crisis of faith'
Germany ordained 30 men to the priesthood in 2026, up from 25 the previous year. Eleven of the country's 27 dioceses and archdioceses had no new priest this year. Regensburg had one. In 1966, there were 447 ordinations across Germany.
Graf attributed the decline primarily to secularization and anti-Church sentiment rather than celibacy.
"When I entered the seminary in 1977, it was practically an honor for a village and even more for my parents. Today it is unfortunately different. The priestly vocation is a contested profession — the abuse scandal being the key word," he said.
He also pointed to the experience of Germany's Protestant churches as evidence that abolishing celibacy does not solve the underlying problem.
"All our Catholic hot-button issues like celibacy and women's ordination have long been settled by the Protestant church in Germany. Yet it now also suffers from personnel shortages and ongoing membership losses," Graf said.
"I say that with no 'schadenfreude,' certainly not. But one can see that the root of the problems lies elsewhere. It is the decline of faith."
Fulda plenary ahead
Graf's public remarks were made less than two weeks before Germany's bishops convene for their autumn plenary in Fulda from Sept. 28 to Oct. 1. The agenda under new conference president Bishop Heiner Wilmer includes surrogacy, assisted suicide, organ donation, artificial intelligence, and sexual abuse.
Wilmer, the bishop of Münster and a member of the Priests of the Sacred Heart, was elected president of the German Bishops' Conference in February. In an interview with Vatican News published Sept. 16, he called for renewal.
"We need not be afraid of renewal," Wilmer said. "Nor need we be afraid of the spirit of the times, which shows us how to proclaim the Gospel well today."
Wilmer argued that a synodal Church is essential for Europe. "Europe urgently needs a synodal Church, because Europe is becoming ever more complex, ever more fragmented. The danger is that Europe falls apart, descends into petty statism, and there are skirmishes," he said.
The statutes for Germany's planned Synodal Conference — a controversial, permanent body that would give laypeople a formal advisory role alongside bishops — remain pending approval from the Holy See. Wilmer submitted the text to the Vatican on March 31. The conference's inaugural meeting, originally planned for November in Stuttgart, has been postponed until Rome's response is finalized.
This story was first published in two parts by CNA Deutsch, the German-language sister service of EWTN News. It has been translated and adapted by EWTN News English.
Full Article