JERUSALEM — The Coalition of Catholics Against Antisemitism (CCAA), a lay-led U.S. organization established in late 2023 that "affirms the right of the Jewish people to live safely and securely in their ancestral homeland" as well as recognizes that "modern Israel is essential to that security," has emerged as a leading resource in the Government of Israel's outreach to American Catholics, who constitute the country's largest single religious constituency.
Tammy Ben-Haim, head of religious and interfaith affairs at Israel's Ministry of Foreign Affairs, told EWTN news that a May meeting in Washington, D.C., with CCAA Director Simone Rizkallah, a first-generation American of Egyptian-Armenian descent, convinced her of the importance of engaging the organization and its supporters.
"I was so impressed by Simone and the vision she had for the organization to combat antisemitism," including CCAA's network of key influencers throughout the American Catholic world, Ben-Haim said.
Signatories to the CCAA's "Statement of Solidarity and Action," a statement developed in the wake of the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attack against Israel that also affirms the above-referenced right of the Jewish people "should not jeopardize the right of Palestinians to also live in safety and security," include dozens of the country's top Catholic thought leaders and personalities.
"When Israel's Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA) decided to begin engaging Catholics more proactively and wanted to design a trip specifically for Catholic leaders, it made sense that they would reach out to us," Rizkallah said.
As a result, in August Rizkallah coordinated with the MFA a weeklong itinerary for 13 American Catholic influencers that addressed firsthand both concerns for the security of Israelis in the country's Gaza and Lebanon border regions as well as honest discussions with Israeli Arab and Palestinian Catholics about the conditions and challenges they face.
Signaling the importance of the initiative, the government of Israel highlighted the group's visit on social media, noting that the journey of the American Catholic community leaders was one of "friendship and solidarity" that served to both "deepen their commitment to standing against antisemitism and strengthening the bonds between Christians and Jews."
Instagram post< async defer src="//www.instagram.com/embed.js">
During the visit, the group, which included representatives from various U.S. Catholic educational institutions, media, think tanks, and lay apostolates, came face-to-face with the existential threats Israel has faced in recent years. The group visited sites of the Oct. 7, 2023, invasions into Israel by thousands of Hamas militants from Gaza, meeting with survivors of the attacks that killed over 1,000 Israelis.
From a mountaintop overlooking Israel's border with southern Lebanon and as multiple explosions could be heard in the distance, the group received a sobering briefing on Israel Defense Forces (IDF) operations to neutralize the threat from Hezbollah in the neighboring country.
In addition, the Government of Israel facilitated the group's direct interaction with various Christians in the disputed lands internationally known as the West Bank (known in Israel by their biblical names of Judea and Samaria) as well as in Haifa, in northern Israel. To varying degrees, these Christians also see themselves as facing existential threats.
The group's guide in Bethlehem, the Palestinian-controlled West Bank town of Jesus' birth, lamented that just in recent weeks the town has lost several leading Christian families, who have emigrated to Greece.
Bethlehem continues to experience a devastating loss of its Christian population. From once having constituted a robust majority, the percentage of Christians there is now estimated in the single digits, with conditions for those remaining further exacerbated by the dearth of pilgrims and severe limitations, since the atrocities of Oct. 7, on permissions for Palestinians to enter Israel for work.
In Haifa, the group met with Archbishop Youssef Matta of the Melkite Greek Catholic Church, Israel's largest Christian community. Melkite Greek Catholics represent nearly 40% of Israel's total Christian population of 185,000. Nazareth, Haifa, and Jerusalem, respectively, are the country's largest Christian population centers.
In a meeting also attended by Ben-Haim and Cesare Marijeh, senior director of the Christian Department of Israel's Ministry of Interior Affairs, Matta addressed several challenges facing his community, including alleged extortion rackets by Muslim and Jewish organized crime families as well as discrimination in government subsidies for the Church's schools, of which there are five under his jurisdiction.
At a luncheon with the delegation, Monsignor Simon Khoury, a Melkite Greek Catholic priest who serves a parish in Cana, asserted that the government has deliberately turned a blind eye to the criminal extortion rackets faced by Christians, as he believes such crimes align with the agenda of certain sectors of Israeli society that favor the displacement of the country's non-Jewish population.
From the beginning to the end of the trip, members of the delegation pressed Israeli authorities to provide necessary assistance to and security for the country's Christian population, contending that such actions will go a long way toward bolstering goodwill toward Israel among hundreds of millions of Catholics worldwide.
At a meeting of the group with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs' director of the Department for Combating Antisemitism, Arezoo Hersel-Rohila, and the Anti-Defamation League's Israel director, Carole Nuriel, EWTN News asked them to identify and address the principal antisemitic narrative that the country is currently facing at the international level.
Both women agreed in answering that it is equating Israel's policy in Gaza to that of the Nazis, i.e., the charge that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza. The officials vigorously contested this widespread allegation, citing that by definition genocide requires intent and that in contravention of such intent, Israel's military has repeatedly sought to relocate Palestinian civilians within Gaza to get them out of harm's way as it targets Hamas' terrorist infrastructure.
Other organizations that also address this question, such as the American Jewish Committee (AJC), assert that the IDF "still endeavors to warn Gazans prior to attacks and has allowed humanitarian aid for civilians to be delivered under arrangements intended to prevent Hamas from diverting aid or controlling its distribution to reinforce its authority."
Israel's government also answers the charge by pointing to evidence that Hamas has repeatedly called on Palestinian civilians to ignore Israel's warnings about impending strikes, in effect using them as human shields. Defenders of Israel's actions in Gaza, like the AJC, also note that "international law does not prohibit Israel from undertaking legitimate actions that will likely result in civilian harm unless the expected civilian harm will clearly exceed the anticipated military advantage from the attack."
As the ADL and much of the Jewish community worldwide see it, the propagation of antisemitic narratives around Israel's operations in Gaza have particularly proliferated among social media influencers, including some Catholics.
This also explains in part the why a wide range of U.S. Catholic influencers who personally stand in support of the CCAA's statement of solidarity, including participants affiliated with EWTN News, the Ethics and Public Policy Center, the Institute on Religion and Democracy, the National Catholic Prayer Breakfast, the Family Research Council, the GIVEN Institute, Tepeyac Leadership, Benedictine College, and the Franciscan University of Steubenville, among others, were invited to engage firsthand with these ongoing issues.
Ben-Haim, who accompanied the delegation on the Stations of the Cross route in Jerusalem's Old City, told EWTN News that going forward, she would like to see more such delegations, especially "young up-and-coming Catholic leaders and influencers" have similar experiences.
"No amount of explaining or telling our story equals one visit to Israel," Ben-Haim explained. Noting that terrorist organizations like Hamas and Hezbollah are right at the country's borders, she insisted that "all that I believe Israel and Israelis want is for people around the world to understand this; we want to live in a county and in a region that is peaceful and quiet. We cannot afford to have the Oct. 7, 2023, massacre happen again; we cannot allow our borders to be crossed and our children and families to be murdered for being Jews and Israelis."
