Catholic News

null / Credit: Brian A Jackson/Shutterstock

Washington, D.C. Newsroom, Jul 22, 2025 / 15:46 pm (CNA).

Massachusetts federal judge Indira Talwani on Tuesday issued a ruling blocking the provision in the "One Big Beautiful Bill" that stopped taxpayer funding of Planned Parenthood and other abortion centers.

In the July 21 ruling, Talwani unilaterally decided that the law does not apply to abortion businesses like Planned Parenthood and granted the organization's request for a temporary injunction while the lawsuit progresses.

Planned Parenthood sued the administration in the Planned Parenthood v. Kennedy lawsuit challenging the provision in the recent reconciliation bill that sought to prohibit abortion centers from receiving Medicaid reimbursements for one year. The case stated the "Defund Provision" violates the First Amendment, the equal protection clause, and the bill of attainder clause of the Constitution. 

Another affected abortion center, Maine Family Planning, also filed a similar lawsuit against the Trump administration seeking to restore Medicaid funding.

Marjorie Dannenfelser, president of the political group Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America, called the decision "a desperate attempt to run out the clock and a shameful abuse of our tax dollars."

In a statement, SBA Pro-Life America slammed the ruling, reporting that "every day the order remains in effect, Planned Parenthood continues to rake in millions from American taxpayers."

"Every day her decision remains in effect, millions are funneled into a business that profits from ending unborn lives and putting women at risk," Dannenfelser said. "Planned Parenthood's desperate ploy for our tax dollars only underscores why the One Big Beautiful Bill is such a historic win. It halted, for the first time, over half a billion taxpayer dollars from propping up the corrupt abortion industry."

"Life is winning. And Big Abortions' death grip is slipping. With community health centers outnumbering Planned Parenthood facilities 15 to 1, women have better and more comprehensive alternatives. We look forward to the Trump administration swiftly ending this lawfare and restoring the historic victory secured through the One Big Beautiful Bill," Dannenfelser concluded. 

Other pro-life organizations have also spoken out following the decision. Students for Life of America reported in a post to social media platform X that the decision by the "unelected judge … forced Americans to hand $800 million to Planned Parenthood — the nation's largest abortion vendor."

"The courts are protecting death and the abortion industry, not the 402,000 innocent babies that Planned Parenthood kills each year," the post concluded.

Lila Rose, founder of global pro-life organization Live Action, called Talwani "a rogue district judge" who is "trying to force Americans to keep bankrolling killing children."

Rose called the ruling "blatant judicial abuse" and urged the Trump administration to "appeal immediately."

Full Article